What to Buy, a Notebook or Desktop PC?

Features
By
published

$1850 vs. $1850: Benchmarks

In order to give you an idea of what you can expect for a certain price, we compared the Acer Aspire 6920G-814G32BN, which is available through online shops for about $1850, with a desktop system of the same price. The results are not surprising, but they can serve as a guideline if you are still unsure of which system is right for you.

Acer 6920G-814G32BN

CPUMotherboardRAMHard Disk DriveBD-ROMWirelessScreenGraphics CardSound CardPower Supply

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Platform
Intel Core 2 Duo T8100 (45 nm; 2100 MHz, 3 MB L2 Cache)
Mobile Intel PM965 Express Chipset
2x 2048 MB DDR2-667 SDRAM
Western Digital WD3200BEVT320 GB, 5,400 RPM, 8 MB Cache, SATA2/300
Blu-ray Disc Drive with DVD-SuperMultiBD-R/-RE/-ROM/DVD+-RW/+R DL/RAM
Intel 4965AGN WLAN (802.11a/g/n) Mini-card
16″ Widescreen WXGA LCD (1366x768) Acer CineCrystal
Nvidia GeForce 9500M-GS 512 MB dedicated VRAM
Integrated
4400 mAh Primary Battery

OSDirectX VersionPlatform DriversGraphics Drivers

Swipe to scroll horizontally
System Software & Drivers
Windows Vista Enterprise 6.0 Build 6001 SP1
10
Intel Version 8.2.0.1014
Nvidia Display Drivers 174.51 (7.15.11.7451)

Tom’s Hardware personal configuration

CPUIntel Platform S775Intel P35MemoryDVD-ROMHard Disk DriveGraphics CardPower adapter

Swipe to scroll horizontally
System Hardware
Intel Core 2 Duo E8400 (45 nm, 3.00 GHz, 6 MB L2 Cache)
Gigabyte EP35C-DS3R, Rev. 1.0
Intel P35, BIOS: F3B
2x 2GB DDR2-800 G.Skill F2-6400CL5D-4GBPQ
Samsung SH-D163A, SATA150
Samsung Spinpoint F1 HD753LJ 750 GB, 7,200 RPM, 32MB Cache, SATA2/300
GeForce 8800 GTS 320MB
Zalman, ATX 2.01, 510 Watt

OSDirectX VersionPlatform DriversGraphics Drivers

Swipe to scroll horizontally
System Software & Drivers
Windows Vista Enterprise 6.0 Build 6001 SP1
10
Intel Version 8.2.0.1014
Nvidia Display Drivers 169.75
Marcel Binder
Marcel Binder
27 Comments Comment from the forums
  • Oakley707
    How does Tom's computer for 1850$ actually cost 1850$? Seems much lower than that... a 8800 gts (320 meg...?) seems weird!
    Reply
  • spearhead
    with the desktop you could get an even better card then 8800gts 320mb for the cash. 8800gt or 3870x2 and such could give you an advatage for 1850 i could build a far better system and that is true. if not for the graphics notebooks these days are great. they only need to get some upgradebility of the mxm module for us costumers for acceptable pricings then we can more to more mobile solutions. we just want more gaming power for lower prices :)
    we shall soon see faster mobile solutions. the hybrid graphic solutions of the puma platform might offer good preformance for low pricing.
    Reply
  • njalterio
    Overall good article except...

    1)There was no mention of overclocking.
    2)The Tom's guide computer was poorly built for the price. I could easily have included a 3870 X2 and two more GB of RAM. No mention of what case was used....although that probably would not have significantly impact the benchmarks.
    3)Is there some kind of behind the scenes advertising here? Whats with the Samsung/Nvidia only usage? (Intel I can understand for obvious reasons)

    With two more GB of RAM, the 3870X2 (which I am certain would stay within the price range), and a good overclock the desktop computer would have wrecked that laptop in benchmarks!

    Would have been interesting to see a MacBook tested against these computers as well.
    Reply
  • coldmast
    8800gts 320mb? ~$120

    ROTFLMFAO

    give us a cost breakdown on each part of the system spec (desktop)
    are you including the display cost for the desktop (22"ers are at a great price point $200-$350)

    keyboard, mouse? $40-$120

    Desktop and NetBook
    Reply
  • Shadow703793
    spearheadwith the desktop you could get an even better card then 8800gts 320mb for the cash. 8800gt or 3870x2 and such could give you an advatage for 1850 i could build a far better system and that is true. if not for the graphics notebooks these days are great. they only need to get some upgradebility of the mxm module for us costumers for acceptable pricings then we can more to more mobile solutions. we just want more gaming power for lower prices we shall soon see faster mobile solutions. the hybrid graphic solutions of the puma platform might offer good preformance for low pricing.njalterioOverall good article except...1)There was no mention of overclocking. 2)The Tom's guide computer was poorly built for the price. I could easily have included a 3870 X2 and two more GB of RAM. No mention of what case was used....although that probably would not have significantly impact the benchmarks.3)Is there some kind of behind the scenes advertising here? Whats with the Samsung/Nvidia only usage? (Intel I can understand for obvious reasons)With two more GB of RAM, the 3870X2 (which I am certain would stay within the price range), and a good overclock the desktop computer would have wrecked that laptop in benchmarks!Would have been interesting to see a MacBook tested against these computers as well.Agreed.
    Reply
  • coldmast
    these article are always good but some lack proper depth,
    it would be nice to do a series of articles addressing different aspects.

    Cheap Notebooks vs Cheap Desktops

    Desktop Replacements {17"+ screen size} vs Workstations (CAD related)

    Designer Notebooks (Stylish & Elegant) vs Designer Desktops / media centers (Stylish & Elegant)

    and most importantly

    GAMING Notebooks vs GAMING Desktops @~$1500 ~$2200 ~$3000
    Reply
  • garydale
    I've been listening to talk about how notebook computers are catching up to desktop performance for decades now and it still hasn't happened. At any given price point, you can always get greater performance from a desktop system. That's not likely to change.

    However, several issues that weren't raised that should be. When a notebook breaks down, it's often cheaper to get a new notebook if its out of warranty. With a desktop system, just swap out the failed part and continue on.

    I've seen lots of notebook failures too. They just don't seem to be as reliable as desktop systems. Even rescuing the data following a notebook failure is a real pain. The HD interface keeps changing and doing a disk-to-disk copy from one notebook drive to another is impossible - notebooks can't handle two hard drives at once. This means booting from a Linux live cd with the drive you want to copy in a working notebook, then copying the files to an external (usb) drive or a network share.

    Students seem to think notebooks are great - very portable. Yes, and that makes them easy to steal too. If you know a student who wants a computer, do them a favour and get them something big and heavy.

    And how about ergonomics? The miniature keyboard with the screen positioned too low relative to your eye level is asking for problems. Then there is the built-in pointing device. Sorry, but there's a reason why they're not used on desktop system - a mouse simply works better.

    With USB keys going dirt cheap these days, get two or more desktop systems and keep one every place you normally do work. Use a USB key to transfer documents, or share them on the Internet. Of if you want to be able to move a system around, there are some very small desktop systems you can get.

    I'm not saying that notebooks don't have their uses. However, a replacement for a desktop system isn't one of them.
    Reply
  • That acer is uuuuuuugly.
    Reply
  • onearmedscissorb
    It's not hard at all to find a decent selection of very similar laptops with 8600M GT/9500M GS graphics, but with T9300 processors, for $1,300 to $1,400.

    So the laptop price isn't making sense to me, either, but I guess that evens it out some.

    If they're going to allow a budget of pretty much $2,000 and basically directly compare laptops to desktops, what they should have done is used a laptop based on desktop components, as that's what the decent ones tend to start at.
    Reply
  • dmacfour
    With $1850 you could get a laptop with a much better video card. $1300 will get you one with an 8800m GTS.
    Reply