Russian-Made Elbrus CPUs Fail Trials, 'A Completely Unacceptable Platform'

MCST
(Image credit: MCST)

SberInfra, a technology arm of Sber, Russia's biggest bank, has evaluated the Russian-made MCST Elbrus-8C processors in multiple workloads, but the results were utterly disappointing and the processors failed the test. The testers cited "Insufficient memory, slow memory, few cores, low frequency. Functional requirements not been met at all" as key reasons for the failure. However, there is hope, according to SberInfra engineers.

Homebrew Hardware…

Anton Shilov
Contributing Writer

Anton Shilov is a contributing writer at Tom’s Hardware. Over the past couple of decades, he has covered everything from CPUs and GPUs to supercomputers and from modern process technologies and latest fab tools to high-tech industry trends.

  • Alvar "Miles" Udell
    It only took AMD 5 years and a shoestring budget to design the Zen architecture from scratch, all it takes is the right people.
    Reply
  • Co BIY
    I think the size of the potential market is key to justify the investment.

    This is why China's efforts for silicon independence are a lot more likely to succeed. A lot larger market and greater global market penetration.

    Russia can probably find more "bang" for their strategic "buck" elsewhere.
    Reply
  • Endymio
    In an attempt perhaps to justify the misleading headline, the author left out one of Zhbankov's most salient conclusions: that the issues largely didn't appear due to the CPU themselves, but rather in the assembly of the particular servers involved in the testing.
    Reply
  • VforV
    Endymio said:
    In an attempt perhaps to justify the misleading headline, the author left out one of Zhbankov's most salient conclusions: that the issues largely didn't appear due to the CPU themselves, but rather in the assembly of the particular servers involved in the testing.
    If that is true, it would only follow the trend of unprofessional tech press we've seen for some years now...
    Reply
  • pavel.mateja
    They should throw away their proprietary VLIW-like architecture and go RISC-V way.
    They might even be able to sell some outside of Russia and SW support would be on different level.
    Reply
  • IntelUser2000
    Surprise, surprise.

    The original talk of Elbrus came during the time when Intel was still selling various Itanium chips back in 2004! And they are still on 28nm. 3x slower for 1/3rd the cores, 1/6th threads and 2/3rds the Base Xeon clocks and lacking Turbo is really not bad at all.

    Newsflash: CPU from 2018 outperforms CPU from 2004 significantly! Pentium 4 beats Pentium II! Bulldozer beats Core 2!

    Alvar Miles Udell said:
    It only took AMD 5 years and a shoestring budget to design the Zen architecture from scratch, all it takes is the right people.

    The architecture doesn't seem that terrible based on core count/clocks and how it performs.

    The real issue is not getting on at least the 14nm process and having more cores than latest Intel/AMD consumer desktop chips.
    Reply
  • ZorBG
    DavidC1 said:
    Surprise, surprise.

    The original talk of Elbrus came during the time when Intel was still selling various Itanium chips back in 2004! And they are still on 28nm. 3x slower for 1/3rd the cores, 1/6th threads and 2/3rds the Base Xeon clocks and lacking Turbo is really not bad at all.

    Newsflash: CPU from 2018 outperforms CPU from 2004 significantly! Pentium 4 beats Pentium II! Bulldozer beats Core 2!

    Tom's Hardware was very good site back in the day. Very professional, accurate, and above all didn't mix politics with hardware.

    I am sad to see some 8-core trial processor is compared with Intel 2K USD 40-core madness... No wonder its slower...
    Reply
  • husker
    ZorBG said:
    Tom's Hardware was very good site back in the day. Very professional, accurate, and above all didn't mix politics with hardware.

    I am sad to see some 8-core trial processor is compared with Intel 2K USD 40-core madness... No wonder its slower...
    You seemed to miss the point of the article. This wasn't a Tom's Hardware review, but it simply a report on what happened. In Russia. By Russians. If the Russians* are comparing mismatched processors, well then darn those pesky Russians*!
    The mention of politics (Crimea, Ukraine) in the article are not introduced by Tom's as some kind of statement, but merely serve to inform the reader as to why the Russians* are developing a new processor in the first place.

    * Note: No disrespect is meant against Russia, Russian citizens, or Russian companies. Some of my favorite hockey players are Russian.
    Reply
  • Icho
    pavel.mateja said:
    They should throw away their proprietary VLIW-like architecture and go RISC-V way.
    They might even be able to sell some outside of Russia and SW support would be on different level.
    Changing, why? Finding that a 70W processor is twice slower than a 125W one means parity in "performance/Watt". And when one achives parity with 28nm process vs Intel's 14 nm one, that is telling big things about the archtecture. Only the Java results are disapointing here ... So VLIW seems sound approach here.
    Reply
  • blazed
    After Intel and AMD have stopped selling to Russia due to the Ukraine invasion, I'm curious Sberbank won't have a lot of options to purchase CPUs for enterprise work. Will they reconsider? Even if they considered black market for those chips, they wouldn't be able to meet the demand they require, these companies even stopped selling PC/server CPU/APU to Russia. Its interesting to see if these companies preventing the tech sale to Russia will give new life to Elbrus?
    Reply