AMD leaves Linux FPGA users in the lurch with controversial Vivado licensing update — new tier model restricts future free versions to Windows

An AMD Vivado logo image overlaid with Tux the Linux Penguin, who is crossed out with a large red 'X'.
(Image credit: AMD, Larry Ewing)
Latest Videos FromTom's Hardware
TOPICS
Zak Killian
Contributor

Zak is a freelance contributor to Tom's Hardware with decades of PC benchmarking experience who has also written for HotHardware and The Tech Report. A modern-day Renaissance man, he may not be an expert on anything, but he knows just a little about nearly everything.

  • usertests
    AMD's defense on its community forums has also not landed well. The company claimed that 70% of Vivado users are on Windows anyway, alienating the academic researchers, engineering students, and open-source hobbyists who heavily favor Linux-native environments and rely on free tools to learn the trade.
    That's a big Linux share, not the usual 1-5%.

    AMD's forum representative confirmed they were "collecting all the feedback received and passing on to the relevant team/marketing" at AMD, leaving the door ajar for a possible change to this policy down the line.
    That's how it works with AMD. You shout at them until they undo their latest dumb decision.
    Reply
  • gamerk316
    usertests said:
    That's a big Linux share, not the usual 1-5%.
    While I am not in any way a Linux fanboy, the use of Linux in the aerospace industry (where Xilinx now AMD found its footing) has a much higher then average use of Linux.
    Reply
  • LordVile
    usertests said:
    That's a big Linux share, not the usual 1-5%.


    That's how it works with AMD. You shout at them until they undo their latest dumb decision.
    It’s used more in research due to increased performance on bespoke software. I dual booted Linux at university as it significantly sped up the molecular modelling software they used.
    Reply
  • qxp
    Disappointing. It would be better to use open source tools, of course. Is the bitstream format still proprietary?
    Reply
  • suryasans
    AMD is becoming another bad guy for Linux community. Well, it's a corporate greed as usual.
    Reply
  • cp0x
    It's a bit weird how people feel entitled to get other people's work for free.

    This is a stupid and unnecessary change by AMD, but that doesn't negate the fact that it's still a bit weird that people feel entitled to get other people's work for free.
    Reply
  • JakobsenCph
    This is so off - FPGA and the free entry level stuff for the small FPGA from AMD - is the direct path for a career in digital design and chip design. And as the industry and AMD need our next generation to do chip design. I do not get the point.
    I have done chip design for 30 year - we use Linux for very obvious reasons - and the faster we get student on Linux the faster we get a new god chip designer.
    I would never point any student in the direction of any of the onetime use vender lockin platforms.
    We have much cheaper FPGA dev board like Tanknano 9k/20k that is fully supported by the Linux foundation back open source tools like Yosys and Nextpnr.
    Reply