AI vibe-coded operating system is so bad it can't even run Doom — Vib-OS can't connect to the internet, browser app is an image viewer [Updated]
OS scrapes through the test, scoring deceptively respectable five out of nine.
Update: 12.51 EST: The developer of Vib-OS, viralcode, has reached out to say that the video concentrated on "x86 64, which is buggy and mentioned in readme." It is further suggested the content of the video was largely negative "just to get views." If readers want to test out Vib-OS properly "QEMU in Mac is the best place to run it without bugs," encourages the developer.
A new vibe-coded operating system was found to be a woeful attempt at building a PC operating system. This revelation comes via TechTuber Tirimid, who put an AI-coded OS through his regular set of nine quality checks. Unfortunately, Vib-OS v2.2.1 - Multi-Architecture OS with Full GUI, was found to be difficult to set up, and was stuffed with a mix of serious and/or weird bugs. Even some of its headlining features, like running Doom, simply didn’t work, as evidenced by the video embedded below.
Checking out the Vib-OS GitHub resources, the operating system seems to cover all the bases for a useful modern OS. The blurb insists this custom Unix-like OS “features a custom kernel, a modern macOS-inspired graphical user interface, a full TCP/IP networking stack, and a Virtual File System (VFS).” Moreover, it works natively on real hardware like Raspberry Pi 4/5, x86_64 PCs, and Apple Silicon – as well as in emulators like QEMU, according to the author (or possibly AI also wrote the readme).
At version 2.2.X, one might expect a project to have gotten past teething issues such as major advertised features having obvious bugs, or not even working. Tirimid’s testing of the system using QEMU on Linux x86 (as specifically stated to be compatible) shows that Vib-OS still needs a few fixes to bring it up to the level of being competent.
For example, installation issues foreshadowed the bugginess that was to follow. After several hours of ‘suffering,’ Tirimid finally managed to get the OS to boot, though.
The OS starts with a familiar-looking desktop, displaying a File Manager, Terminal, a central apps bar at the bottom of the screen, and some status icons appearing to show things like network connection status and time. It was promising to see the OS boot up with these familiar windows open and ready to do as instructed. However, the OS failed at several basic tasks:
- Trying to connect to the internet – failed
- The New Folder button and context menu in File Manager don’t do anything
- The Notepad app doesn’t seem to load or save, and doesn’t recognize arrow key input
- There’s no Python support apparent, despite GitHub assertions to the contrary
- Games don’t appear to be installed and/or don’t work properly
- The calculator doesn’t work using the on-screen keypad, but is OK (except for decimals) when inputting using the keyboard
- The Clock app doesn’t update unless you activate (click) its window, and the time isn’t the same as the system time in the status bar
- The ‘Browser’ app is an image viewer
The operating system allegedly supports Doom. The readme includes screens marked “Classic Doom running natively with full graphics, input, and sound support.” And it is claimed, independently, that there is a “Full Doom port with graphics, input, and sound” in the OS. Nevertheless, Tirimid’s clicking of the Doom icon in the launcher did nothing.
Get Tom's Hardware's best news and in-depth reviews, straight to your inbox.
Giving up on Doom, a pre-installed version of Snake ran, but had serious issues with screen updates and pacing. This poorly executed game managed to get Vib-OS a tick on Tirimid’s 9-point checklist as it technically ran.
Finally, the TechTuber couldn’t even ‘destroy’ this OS from within. It was very limited in understanding Terminal commands, meaning that “even something like a file deletion won’t be possible.”
Tirimid has previously tested other interesting operating systems like RetrOS, Hannah Montana Linux, and Windows XP.
Follow Tom's Hardware on Google News, or add us as a preferred source, to get our latest news, analysis, & reviews in your feeds.
Mark Tyson is a news editor at Tom's Hardware. He enjoys covering the full breadth of PC tech; from business and semiconductor design to products approaching the edge of reason.
-
DS426 ReplyTirimid’s testing of the system using QEMU on Linux x86 (as specifically stated to be compatible) shows that Vib-OS still needs a few fixes to bring it up to the level of being competent. - this article
A "few" fixes? Who knows how many hundreds or maybe thousands of software vulnerabilities are lurking in this OS. I would not even test this out while being connected to the internet. Sure, most wouldn't have anything important in terms of personal and sensitive data, but a bad actor could probably fairly easily plant a bootkit that can survive OS wipes and even HDD/SDD replacements (if embedded in UEFI for example). Hopefully that device never gets used for anything other than testing, and even then, it could be a launchpad for lateral attacks on the network.
Yes, AI can help reduce vulnerabilities from even being introduced in source and before compiling, but vulnerabilities also tend to be introduced to otherwise wouldn't be. Looking at it through that lens, this would be an interesting experiment in evaluating the secure coding capabilities of the AI used. Interesting to me, anyways. :P -
Edward Jazzhands I read the project readme and I can absolutely guarantee you that readme is 100% AI generated. You can tell by how many emojis there are, excessive use of bullet points, and also how extremely long it is. Those are all classic signs that it was machine generated. There is almost nobody who vibe codes and also writes the readme by hand. I wouldn't be surprised at all to learn that the project creator hasn't tried to verify many of the claimed features.Reply -
ravewulf If only examples like this would convince those investing in AI that the bubble needs to be deflated...Reply -
John musbach Reply
Why is using Windows XP notable?Admin said:A new vibe-coded operating system performed as woefully as expected during a 9-point check process.
AI vibe-coded operating system is so bad it can't even run Doom — Vib-OS can't connect to the internet, browser app is an image viewer : Read more -
USAFRet Reply
Other than what is said about the authors prev experience, where is XP referenced?John musbach said:Why is using Windows XP notable? -
John musbach Reply
That's it but I don't understand what's noteworthy about testing xp unless he's gen z or somethingUSAFRet said:Other than what is said about the authors prev experience, where is XP referenced?