US government warned Anthropic that Fable 5 had been jailbroken, but firm 'refused' to fix before US implemented export controls — Anthropic defended its decision by saying the jailbreak 'isn’t serious,' Chinese group had reportedly accessed model

Anthropic Claude Fable
(Image credit: Getty Images)

David Sacks, co-chair of the President's Council of Advisors on Science and Technology and the administration's former AI czar, said the U.S. government warned Anthropic that Claude Fable 5 had been jailbroken and that CEO Dario Amodei refused to fix the flaw or pull the model. In a post on X on Saturday, Sacks laid out the administration's account a day after it ordered both Fable 5 and Mythos 5 disabled worldwide. Sacks said the administration issued the export control "reluctantly" after that refusal, that it wants the restriction lifted once the jailbreak is patched, and that "the ball is in Anthropic's court."

Sacks claims that a trusted partner of both Anthropic and the U.S. government, testing Fable, came forward with a jailbreak of the guardrails that separate the consumer model from the unrestricted cyber capabilities of Mythos, the model it’s built on. He said the administration asked Amodei to fix the bypass or de-deploy the model, and that Amodei declined. Anthropic instead prioritized keeping its consumer model live over safety, Sacks wrote, calling that inconsistent with the company's positioning as a safety-first lab that had itself lobbied for Mythos to be regulated as a cyberweapon.

Latest Videos FromTom's Hardware
Luke James
Contributor

Luke James is a freelance writer and journalist.  Although his background is in legal, he has a personal interest in all things tech, especially hardware and microelectronics, and anything regulatory. 

  • TechieTwo
    Hold them accountable.
    Reply
  • sanitycheck
    So let me see if I have this straight. Anthropic made Mythos available to a small number of trusted high-end Western tech players. One of them leaked access to China, but we don't know which one. Amazon's CEO used a standard jailbreak technique that all LLMs are vulnerable to in order to "prove" to Sacks that Mythos is dangerous (while the other LLMs are supposedly not dangerous with the same weakness, with no evidence to back up such an absurd claim). Anthropic was ordered to fix it for Mythos, but the other LLMs were not similarly ordered. When Anthropic couldn't fix it fast enough, that means that they "refused" the order. So therefore this is all Anthropic's fault. What part of this farce am I missing?
    Reply
  • Gururu
    sanitycheck said:
    So let me see if I have this straight. Anthropic made Mythos available to a small number of trusted high-end Western tech players. One of them leaked access to China, but we don't know which one. Amazon's CEO used a standard jailbreak technique that all LLMs are vulnerable to in order to "prove" to Sacks that Mythos is dangerous (while the other LLMs are supposedly not dangerous with the same weakness, with no evidence to back up such an absurd claim). Anthropic was ordered to fix it for Mythos, but the other LLMs were not similarly ordered. When Anthropic couldn't fix it fast enough, that means that they "refused" the order. So therefore this is all Anthropic's fault. What part of this farce am I missing?
    The part where Anthropic rejected Pentagon and was outcast. Thus becoming fair game for retribution by junior high government.
    Reply
  • usertests
    TechieTwo said:
    Hold them accountable.
    Yes. Give the jailbreakers a medal. All AI models should be "jailbroken" and twisted to suit whatever our purposes are.
    Reply
  • Dr3ams
    AI rules and laws haven't been solidified yet, so in these battles there are no war crimes being commited. Regardless if it's fair or not, AI developers are going to have to conform or be cast out.

    A quote from Gemini (AI):
    Comprehensive, solidified AI laws are still highly fragmented. Because AI evolves faster than the legislative process, lawmakers globally are scrambling to balance safety with innovation. While there is no single global rulebook, significant frameworks and guidelines are in effect.

    Europe has the world’s most comprehensive AI legislation. The landmark EU AI Act divides AI into four risk levels, completely banning systems that pose unacceptable risks (like manipulative subliminal AI or social scoring) while placing strict transparency, testing, and documentation requirements on "high-risk" systems.

    The United States lacks a unified federal AI law, and policies have been shaped by a mix of state-level laws (such as in California and Colorado) and executive orders. States have focused on specific areas like deepfakes and automated employment decisions, though debate continues on how to unify these rules at the national level.

    Even where laws have passed, governments are struggling with the enforcement infrastructure. Regulatory bodies are actively working to draft specific rules (like how to accurately label AI-generated content or deepfakes) so that existing laws are actually enforceable.
    Reply
  • The Historical Fidelity
    sanitycheck said:
    So let me see if I have this straight. Anthropic made Mythos available to a small number of trusted high-end Western tech players. One of them leaked access to China, but we don't know which one. Amazon's CEO used a standard jailbreak technique that all LLMs are vulnerable to in order to "prove" to Sacks that Mythos is dangerous (while the other LLMs are supposedly not dangerous with the same weakness, with no evidence to back up such an absurd claim). Anthropic was ordered to fix it for Mythos, but the other LLMs were not similarly ordered. When Anthropic couldn't fix it fast enough, that means that they "refused" the order. So therefore this is all Anthropic's fault. What part of this farce am I missing?
    A lot of stuff
    Reply
  • phead128
    You can justify any "ban" these days by saying "China Bad" , it's almost like a joke.

    Dude, one random from China can have access to a model, so we have to ban it for everyone. Even at face value it's ridiculous logic.
    Reply
  • A Stoner
    My guess is that there are several reasons for them letting it get ganked off the market. Token costs were costing it too much. They see this as good publicity even if it hurts their clients, because their clients are not paying enough of the cost of running the program. It sets a precedent they will fully try to force the government to impose on smaller start ups to weed out competition in the future.
    Reply
  • passingbywithanopinion
    Gururu said:
    The part where Anthropic rejected Pentagon and was outcast. Thus becoming fair game for retribution by junior high government.
    Or the other other part where Hegseth today was gloating that the administration got revenge. You can't make this up.
    Reply
  • passingbywithanopinion
    Dr3ams said:
    AI rules and laws haven't been solidified yet, so in these battles there are no war crimes being commited. Regardless if it's fair or not, AI developers are going to have to conform or be cast out.

    A quote from Gemini (AI):
    Please don't post AI slop, we have more capable llms than Gemini we can ask. We're interested in human opinions here.
    Reply