Taiwan refuses to move half of U.S.-bound chip production to American shores — trade discussion to be focused on Section 232 investigation for preferential deal on semiconductors

US and Taiwan flags
(Image credit: Getty Images / NurPhoto)

Taiwanese Vice Premier Cheng Li-chun said on Wednesday, October 1, that his government will not agree to U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick’s proposal to move 50% of chip production bound for the U.S. to American shores.

Sec. Lutnick mentioned the proposal during a recent interview, according to Bloomberg, saying that the U.S. has raised this proposal to reduce its reliance on overseas supply chains. Taiwan was quick to reject the 50-50 suggestion, saying it would not accept the split and that it wasn’t even part of trade talks.

It’s been noted that 70% of its exports are related to semiconductors, and while the U.S. has already imposed a 20% reciprocal tariff on Taiwanese goods, chips and the like have been exempt, so far, pending the result of the White House investigation.

This refusal highlights the high-stakes discussion going on between the two allies. The U.S. naturally wants more of the chips that it needs produced inside the United States, saying that it’s unacceptable that most of the semiconductors that the country relies on are produced in “an island 80 miles from mainland China”. On the other hand, Digitimes reports that Taiwan wants Section 232 exemptions for its number one export, as well as a better tariff deal and a deeper economic partnership between Taipei and Washington.

Taiwan often leverages its global standing as the world’s premier manufacturer of advanced semiconductors as some sort of ‘silicon shield’. Moving over 50% of U.S.-bound chip production from the island into the United States is a risk it might be unwilling to take, as it will reduce China’s biggest rival’s reliance on the island. After all, if its bigger neighbor to the west wrestles control of the country, it could then use Taiwan’s semiconductor expertise to dictate terms to the rest of the world.

Follow Tom's Hardware on Google News, or add us as a preferred source, to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button!

Jowi Morales
Contributing Writer

Jowi Morales is a tech enthusiast with years of experience working in the industry. He’s been writing with several tech publications since 2021, where he’s been interested in tech hardware and consumer electronics.

  • hotaru251
    Taiwan refuses to move half of U.S.-bound chip production to American shores

    even if TSMC had the desire to...I don't think they CAN legally.

    IIRC Taiwan forbids making their newest nodes stuff outside of Taiwan. Its literally a law they can't break.
    Reply
  • JamesJones44
    hotaru251 said:
    even if TSMC had the desire to...I don't think they CAN legally.

    IIRC Taiwan forbids making their newest nodes stuff outside of Taiwan. Its literally a law they can't break.
    That's my understanding as well, it would require a change to their laws in order to approve such a deal which seems unlikely to occur.
    Reply
  • S58_is_the_goat
    hotaru251 said:
    even if TSMC had the desire to...I don't think they CAN legally.

    IIRC Taiwan forbids making their newest nodes stuff outside of Taiwan. Its literally a law they can't break.
    Easy peasy, if Taiwan wants US destroyers on its coast lines protecting them they'll change the laws overnight. Who else will come to their aid if China gets bored?
    Reply
  • heffeque
    S58_is_the_goat said:
    Easy peasy, if Taiwan wants US destroyers on its coast lines protecting them they'll change the laws overnight. Who else will come to their aid if China gets bored?
    This basically summarizes US's foreign policy: bullying countries to do their bidding.
    Reply
  • Dntknwitall
    There would most likely be a loss of revenue and jobs if Taiwan were to do this. This could lead to an upset in the Taiwan economy and could easily make social constructs unstable. Taiwan exists due to its brilliance, not because it has chip manufacturers. Taiwan is full of brilliant minds and engineers. They know what would happen if they moved half their work to another country. The US needs to slow down and stop trying to destroy countries for its financial gain.
    Reply
  • S58_is_the_goat
    heffeque said:
    This basically summarizes US's foreign policy: bullying countries to do their bidding.
    Current foreign policy, yes, lots of bullying coming from them on all fronts imo.
    Reply
  • King_V
    hotaru251 said:
    even if TSMC had the desire to...I don't think they CAN legally.

    IIRC Taiwan forbids making their newest nodes stuff outside of Taiwan. Its literally a law they can't break.
    Yes, but we've already seen that the current US administration has demanded that European nations not penalize American companies for violating European laws. This seems like the same pattern.
    Reply
  • KennyRedSocks
    heffeque said:
    This basically summarizes US's foreign policy: bullying countries to do their bidding.

    Bullying through the lack of force?
    Wouldn't that be reverse-bullying?
    Reply
  • mangaTom
    S58_is_the_goat said:
    Easy peasy, if Taiwan wants US destroyers on its coast lines protecting them they'll change the laws overnight. Who else will come to their aid if China gets bored?
    Tbf, if the US doesn't want to get leapfrogged by China overnight in semi-electronics, then they'd be forced to defend Taiwan anyways. Anyways both situations are lose-lose situations to Taiwan and the US so the current status quo is the best compromise for both nations.
    Reply
  • kameljoe23
    Honestly this administration is pretty whacked. There is no way they're going to move any amount of production to the US. The US needs to get over the fact that they think manufacturing is coming back when we know it will never come back. What we should be doing is encouraging important export with zero tariffs. If we can convince every country in the world to go to the zero tariff we can have a free and open market. When there is a free and open market the ability to purchase any goods without restriction will greatly increase our ability and our economy. The administration has ruined the economy and the heart those who pay. Even the largest companies in the world who produced their products overseas are not coming back and they have said so. So why don't we just take advantage of those countries that produce the product that we want at the price point we want without the tariff. If the administration were to lift the tariff and place no restrictions on anything then trillions of dollars can be spent on importing and exporting products.
    Reply